Want the Perfect Horror Novel for High Schoolers?
Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall by Katie Alender, the perfect horror novel for high schoolers

I don’t know about you, but fall has always meant Halloween season to me–not back-to-school. While other teachers are out shopping for school supplies, I’m literally hiding skeletons in my closet before my boyfriend can reprimand me for bringing more decorations in the house. So October for me means pumpkin spice everything, draping cobwebs all over the house, and reading as much horror fiction as I can. For this October, I’m presenting to you Katie Alendar’s The Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall. It’s the perfect horror novel for high schoolers!

Put on your cozy flannel, turn up Alice Cooper, and curl up with an age-appropriate scary story. 

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links that earn me a small commission, at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products that I personally use and love, or think my readers will find useful.

What Drew me to Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall?

I found The Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall because I’ve had an increase in students begging for horror. (I blame the It remake!) The cover is blatantly horror-related and the title reinforces the obvious creep-factor. I figured it would be an easy sell to my fear-loving students.

Ok. Maybe it was an easy sell for me. I’ve always loved the macabre, so the blood-sputtered cover art spoke to me. 

But that student that wears the Nightmare Before Christmas sweatshirt every single day? Yeah, they’ll gravitate towards it too. 

Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall by Katie Alender, the perfect horror novel for high schoolers

What Makes Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall Lit?

The Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall starts like any other horror. The book opens on a family road trip to see the home Delia has recently inherited from her grandmother. 

Except, when the family arrives, the house isn’t just a house. It’s a mansion. And of course, the mansion just happens to be the former home to an all-girls mental institution–lovingly nicknamed “Hysteria Hall” by locals. 

Immediately, the mood is set by the dusty and cavernous halls of the empty Piven Institute. As Delia walks through her inheritance, you’ll have chills running down your back. The abandoned mansion is so creepy, Delia’s parents don’t even want her exploring on her own.

But this is young adult fiction, so she does anyway. 

It becomes clear that while the institution may be closed, the house refuses to let its patients leave. Dead or alive. 

When Delia arrives, the house only sees her as one more naughty girl to be institutionalized. 

There’s no way it’s going to let Delia leave.

While the beginning of the novel has the horror motifs that we all love–creepy old house, mental institution, random bursts of cool air–it takes an unusual twist early on. It’s this twist that, for me, makes The Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall stands out from other books in the genre.

As a horror novel for high schoolers, it is this twist that allows the book to stay true to the genre without becoming predictable.  

Who is the Ideal Reader for Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall?

This book is definitely going to attract the students in your class that love horror. It’s well designed to catch the eye of anyone looking to be creeped out. 

You’ll probably also find that young women will gravitate towards this book more than the guys. I think this often happens with books starring female protagonists, but much of this story is about how society has viewed women in the past. This makes it especially relatable for women.

While The Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall checks a lot of horror boxes, your die-hard gorefest lovers might be left disappointed. The novel starts out creepy and there’s definitely some supernatural spookiness, but it’s not going to give anyone nightmares.

This is part of the appeal for the book to me; it’s not scary enough that parents will complain, but it should fit the horror genre enough for fans to appreciate it. It’s a great horror novel for high schoolers.

That said, if you have a student who just craves bloodshed, this is not the novel. It’s a touch creepy, but not gory.

With a high-interest Lexile score of 690, this text should be very accessible to most young adult readers. It only took one of my strongest readers a couple of days to get through it. 

With spooky season upon us, I recommend book talking this one and putting it out on display with other horror books. You may even want to read an excerpt that describes the mansion. It will give students a feel for Alender’s storytelling and the mood of the tale. 

Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall by Katie Alender, the perfect horror novel for high schoolers

Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall: The Facts

Title: Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall

Author: Katie Alender

Lexile: HL690

Genre: Horror

Setting: Creepy former all-girls mental institute

Main Character: Delia, who inherits her grandmother’s house only to trapped within it herself

Page Numbers: 336

This book is part of my Classroom Library Must-Haves. To see other must-have titles and get my FREE list, sign up for my newsletter below. You can buy The Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall by clicking HERE.

Looking for related books? Allegedly is the story of an alleged baby murderer and is sure to creep out a few of your students. Dread Nation is a unique take on a zombie story, complete with diverse characters.

Leave a Reply

Close Menu
%d bloggers like this: